So apparently their brilliant plan is that markets should never fall and give consistent returns like bonds. What can go wrong?
2 Likes
Yes. Keep taxing the rich until all the rich leave the country. Makes sense perfectly .
Yea they will sacrifice the rest of 70% to save the 30% of tax. Makes sense perfectly.
A para in the article states
"The risks associated with derivatives trading are not merely theoretical. A significant stock market correction can lead to substantial losses, particularly for retail investors engaged in derivatives. These losses could provoke a strong negative behavioral response, with investors feeling “cheated by unseen more considerable forces.”
I mean what are PUTS for ? next candidate for Nobel Prize in Economics
1 Like
No man. They want you to use derivatives for hedging only. It never occurred to them that someone has to take the other side of the bet when I’m hedging.
If someone wants to buy Puts for hedging his portfolio, someone(speculator) has to sell it to him.
If someone wants to sell covered Calls on his stocks, someone(speculator) has to buy it from him.
1 Like
Not gonna happen.
- Already brought back LTCG without removing STT
- Increased STT recently
- With all the noise around fno, cant do anything to ‘incentivize’ it.
Beyond belief if this is actually the thinking of higher ups.
People want to understand - RBI is worry there is no deposit coming , all money is going to mutual fund
see, SEBI and RBI and FM these people will never allow any Indians to grow
are you think they are trying to save retailers, its need to laugh
They kill already USDINR - ,
now Mutual fund inflow is hitting high - SEBI dont like , they give advertisement after words hey will Ban inflow in small cap and Overseas investment
These people are brainless
if they are doing to save retailers - Lot of people will loose Job in finance industry
Unemployment rate will go high -
All are fraud guys believe me - this is INDIA
Your posts in last year or so have become a bit surreal, take care. Whatever will happen will happen, we can only adapt - no point thinking too much about it.
2 Likes
these idiots want people to believe stock market is safe and stable return. They will only come to sense when black swan reality slapped them in face. during covid crash portfolios were protected by hedge, these idiots wants traders to be gone, no traders means no hedge sellers. naked portfolio during black swan event is enough to nuke indian mutual fund industry. This is why fno is important part of market all over the world, traders works like a safety net providing insurance service to portfolios during big crash events.
2 Likes
Answer to the question why, just why?
Amazing way of answering the core question. For people who do not have time, just go to Time stamp 14.40. Latha of CNBC asked the very same question and Chairperson has given her thoughts. Just great.
2 Likes
Thanks for sharing this @neha1101
26:25 has an interesting question about Sebi’s proposal to allow MF to trade in derivatives via a special asset class.
1 Like
Citing an “alarming incident” that he came across, Kela said, “A friend of mine was saying that his mother asked me about F&O. She is 82-year-old and this friend asked her what have you got to do with F&O and what do you want to do? She said that I have nothing to do with F&O. In our house there is housework going on and three carpenters are working. They do not work between 9:15 and 3:30 because they are doing F&O trading and our work has slowed down,” Kela said.
Read more at:
Very funny…
What is ironic is everyone in this forum who has commented is against what SEBI proposes to do, this means these guys are making money… on the contrary, few experts including Nithin had commented majority lose money in these trade…now who to believe or not.
I am not against SEBI. Whatever they are doing is in the best interest of traders and investors.
I think you are displaying your bias. “Everyone” on the forum is not against Sebi’s statements to curb F&O. Also Nithin said “most”, and most doesn’t equal “all”. Plus a lot of regulars here are folks who are not only passionate about trading but are also keen to learn, these attributes tend to make good traders, so you can find quite a few successful ones amongst regulars here. Besides, even if one wants F&O, it doesnt mean he/she is making money. There is no contradiction, its just your inner voice 
6 Likes
They are mature enough to know and understand the risks. If they win it’s great and if they lose they learn.
1 Like
Voice of Indian Option Traders
We are asking SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India) to make the stock market fair for everyone in India. We want to be able to compete with big foreign investors (FIIs) and bring their money back to India. Instead of banning options and futures trading (F&O) and adding strict rules and taxes, we need a fair environment where regular traders can succeed.
Important Points:
-
Competing with FIIs: Indian traders have to compete with big foreign investors who use very advanced computers and robots to trade. These systems don’t have feelings and can make very quick decisions.
-
Humans vs. Machines: Regular traders rely on their own judgment and hopes. It’s important to have rules that help them with their unique challenges.
-
Fair Opportunities: Making the market fair will help more Indian traders feel confident and join in.
Our Request:
- Fair Rules: Don’t create rules that only hurt regular traders.
- Supportive Policies: Make policies that help Indian traders compete fairly with big foreign investors.
- Encourage Growth: Create an environment that helps the Indian stock market grow and thrive.
By making the stock market fair, SEBI can help regular traders reach their potential and support the growth of India’s market.
Ok teacher will ask my lawyer to check what I write before posting as there is a guy who picks up the full stops and comma in this forum and give gyan on bias and inner voice and what not. You tried this long time back and I told not to school me Ok. The same comments holds. Do not get personal.
I’d advice you the same. Back off.
1 Like
All this can be pointed to youtubers and influencers, this is exactly why knowledge used to be kept secret in olden days, too many cooks ruin the broth similarly too many influencers using clickbait to get people to invest into mutual funds, f & o has led to sebi noticing. Too many people have entered the market post covid. Previously people used to be scared of the stock market saying “jua hai” aka gambling etc we need to go back to those days. influencers are ruining the market for actual traders.
Recently a certain finance influencer had made a video on why he was going to go long on bank nifty, most people watching it on yt wont even know the nitty gritty details of such yet believing the video they too will invest/trade and loose money eventually leading to sebi stopping everyone from trading
3 Likes
