IRCTC — Should I Hold for Recovery or Exit Gradually?

I hold 184 shares of IRCTC at an average purchase price of ₹1,057.12 per share. The latest price I observed was around ₹473.

I have held these shares for a considerable period and am currently facing a substantial unrealised loss. I have also received dividends totalling approximately ₹7,687.50.

I do not want to average down or hold indefinitely for another five years just to recover my purchase price.

Could experienced investors please share their fundamental analysis and views on the following?

  1. What are IRCTC’s growth prospects over the next 3–5 years?

  2. Is the current valuation attractive, fair or expensive?

  3. What are the main risks to future earnings and share-price recovery?

  4. Should I continue holding all 184 shares, or consider a phased exit during a recovery?

  5. What business developments or financial results should I monitor before making an exit decision?

Please provide a reasoned analysis based on fundamentals, valuation and risks rather than an unsupported price target.

Thank you.

the ship has already sailed unfortunately, if you exit fully now and there is any bounce or reversal will you be able to mentally digest it, if so exit fully

Thank you for your advice. If i stay for more than 5 years any chance of double else coming out in share rebound in staggered manner is best. Please suggest. quitting price and no. of qty in phased manner and further i wish to deploy sale amount to Bajaj finance ltd., to protect capital in 5 years instead of staying in irctc for another 5 years is this is correct decision else suggest me best stock for fast recovery.

I was thinking what I would do if I was in this position.

  1. Book the loss of nearly 50%? That is too much for a company which is fundamentally good. EPS of 17. Net profit of 330 cr on an average every quarter. Dividend yield 1.6.

  2. By selling and putting the capital in another share, this does not guarantee that share will zoom (it could but it could go down as well or remain stagnant. Opportunity cost issue?

  3. A regular dividend giving stock this IRCTC from the chart I see, so there will some cash flow after tax into the account.

  4. This is only a possibility - buy a small quantity now with fresh cash and sell the same what you bought now increases, this could reduce the average and at the same time you will book capital loss for your existing shares - Tax loss harvesting. Will take long time but better than incur the loss

Since this is Govt owned cannot expect immediate spike to 1000 plus in this market.

conclusion
If I do not need the cash for immediate need, I will hold on to this share and average it down if possible using the dividends. Sell in part as you have thought when it goes up.

Gone through more or less the same situation with two of my shares.

3 Likes

I still remember IRCTC being one of the hottest stocks during its IPO days, with everyone talking about the listing gains. Hard to believe how much it has fallen since!

Fundamentally, though, IRCTC remains a profitable business with strong cash generation and a near-monopoly in railway ticketing, catering and packaged water. However, recent results show revenue growth hasn’t translated into much profit growth, so margins and future earnings are worth watching.

Whether to hold or exit depends on your risk appetite and how much of your portfolio is invested in it. If it’s a small portion and you still believe in its fundamentals, holding could make sense. But if you see better opportunities elsewhere, reallocating some money might be worth considering.

One thing to remember: don’t hold a stock just to recover your buying price.

If i were you i would Ask myself, “Would I buy this stock at its current price if I didn’t already own it?” Have a clear investment thesis and exit plan, and review it periodically rather than holding indefinitely just to break even.

5 Likes

Total dividend 7,687.50 holding since 1860 days some qty and another qty since 1000 days

Exactly - Fully agree.

@ramesh_mvksatya This reply has two parts: facts and my opinion.

Facts

  • Sale cost: On Zerodha, the cost to sell 184 shares at ₹473 is approximately ₹105. The cost has three parts: ₹87 STT, a ₹15.34 DP charge and approximately ₹3 for exchange fees and GST. If you sell on different days, a DP charge occurs on each day.
  • Loss type: Your holding period is more than 12 months for all shares. If you sell now, you get a long-term capital loss of approximately ₹1.07 lakh (184 × ₹584).
  • Set-off: You can use a long-term capital loss only against long-term capital gains. These gains can be from any asset, for example shares, funds, gold or property. You cannot use the loss against short-term gains.
  • Carry-forward: You can keep the unused loss for 8 years. To keep it, you must file ITR-2 or ITR-3 by the due date. The new Income-tax Act did not change these rules.
  • Tax value: The tax on long-term equity gains is 12.5% of the amount above ₹1.25 lakh per financial year. At this rate, the loss can decrease your tax by a maximum of approximately ₹13,400, plus cess.
  • Set-off order: First, the loss decreases your long-term gains. Then, the ₹1.25 lakh exemption decreases the gains that remain. In a year with small gains, you use the loss, but your tax does not decrease. You get the maximum tax decrease only in a year with approximately ₹2.3 lakh or more of long-term gains.
  • Same-day trades: India has no wash-sale rule. If you sell and buy the same stock on the same day, the two trades become one intraday trade.

So the only disadvantage of selling is, you will waste around 105 INR in thin air.

My opinion

I am not a SEBI-registered adviser. If I were in your place, I would

  1. Use this question from @Selvaraj_Prabhakar: “Is IRCTC at ₹473 a good purchase for new money today?” If the answer is no, sell.
  2. Buy an ETF, for example NIFTYBEES, MID150BEES or JUNIORBEES, or another mutual fund.
  3. Keep the ETF or fund. Sell it only when you must use the money for your expenses.
  4. Buy or sell individual shares only if you have deep knowledge or an advantage.
2 Likes

Am not experienced investor, may not provide fundamental analysis but here are my thoughts.
“You should forget the price you paid for a share, otherwise it can become a psychological barrier if the share price subsequently falls.” Anthony Bolton

When you invest you should forget about invested price, calculate new FV and then see it as fresh investment. Do not anchor to price you paid.

“Don’t think about the sell decision. Think about the switch decision.” Sankaran Naren

Unless you form an idea on switch decision no point in selling just because it is at loss.

The estimates look reasonable.

If I am in this situation I would book loss for tax harvesting, Invest in Groww Nifty India Railways PSU Index Fund if I plan to stick with railway theme if not look at other themes for fresh investments. Banks look good.

PS: I hold Groww Nifty India Railways PSU Index Fund , ICICI and SBI.

2 Likes

Holding through a ~55% drawdown is tough, especially when capital gets locked up while other market opportunities move ahead. Below is an objective fundamental breakdown addressing your specific questions to help you decide without emotional bias:

1. Growth Prospects Over the Next 3–5 Years

  • Ticketing Saturation: IRCTC already captures over 80–85% of total Indian Railways reserved bookings online. Because digital penetration is near saturation, revenue growth in this vertical relies primarily on overall passenger traffic growth (single-digit percentage annually) or convenience fee hikes (which are strictly government-regulated).

  • Catering & Hospitality: The primary expansion driver remains onboard catering, food plazas, executive lounges, and branded tourism trains (Bharat Gaurav, Tejas). However, these carry lower operating margins compared to the high-margin Internet Ticketing division.

  • Tourism & Packaged Air/Land Tours: Growing steadily, but competition from online travel aggregators (OTAs) and low-cost operators caps aggressive margin expansion.

  • Realistic Growth Outlook: Sustainable revenue and PAT CAGR over a 3–5 year horizon is expected in the 10%–14% range, rather than the hyper-growth seen right after listing.

2. Is the Current Valuation Attractive, Fair, or Expensive?

  • At prices around the ₹470–₹500 zone, IRCTC trades at a Price-to-Earnings (P/E) multiple roughly in the 38x–45x range.

  • Verdict: While significantly de-rated from its speculative peak valuations (when it traded at 80x–100x P/E), it is fairly to fully valued, not deeply undervalued.

  • A mid-teens earnings growth profile typically commands a 28x–35x multiple for mature monopoly/utility-like PSUs. Therefore, substantial multiple expansion is unlikely to drive outsized returns; future stock appreciation will largely have to track organic earnings growth.

3. Key Risks to Future Earnings & Share Price Recovery

  • Policy & Regulatory Intervention: As a PSU, the biggest lingering overhang is the risk of the Ministry of Railways altering revenue-sharing agreements (e.g., sharing convenience fees, as was briefly proposed in late 2021 before being retracted).

  • Margin Dilution from Segment Mix: If lower-margin catering and tourism grow faster than internet ticketing, overall operating margins contract.

  • Opportunity Cost: To recover from ₹473 back to your purchase price of ₹1,057, the stock needs to rally +123%. At an assumed 12–14% annual earnings compounding rate, organic recovery could take 5 to 7+ years without external speculative re-rating.

4. Holding All 184 Shares vs. Phased Exit Strategy

Holding indefinitely just to see the original purchase price returned is anchored on the “sunk cost fallacy”. Instead of an all-or-nothing binary choice, consider a staggered opportunity-cost reallocation:

  • Tranche 1 (Immediate Relief - 30% to 40%): Exit a portion to harvest the tax loss (which can offset short-term or long-term capital gains across other equities/mutual funds) and redeploy that capital into sectors showing consistent 18–20% earnings visibility.

  • Tranche 2 (Pullback/Bounce Exit - 30%): Place sell limit orders on technical relief rallies (e.g., toward key moving average resistances or post-earnings quarterly bounces).

  • Tranche 3 (The Core Balance): Retain the remaining 30–40% to continue collecting the consistent dividend stream and participate if a multi-year PSU infrastructure tailwind accelerates earnings faster than expected.

5. Key Metrics & Developments to Monitor

Before pulling the trigger on any phase of your exit:

  1. Quarterly Internet Ticketing EBIT Margin: Watch whether operating margins in the ticketing segment remain above 80%. Any decline indicates cost pressures or policy friction.

  2. Convenience Fee Structure: Track any railway ministry circulars regarding convenience fee caps or sharing mandates.

  3. Catering Volume vs. Margin: Check if the expansion into new Vande Bharat trains and food plazas is translating into bottom-line cash flow or merely top-line revenue inflation.

  4. Dividend Yield Sustainability: Track whether payout ratios remain healthy (>50% of PAT) to ensure the cost of holding continues to yield regular cash returns.

(Note: This analysis is for educational and strategic evaluation purposes. Please factor in your overall portfolio allocation, risk tolerance, and tax situation before executing)

All depends on macro & micro eco factors. As u hold many lots first of all whether u decide to book a loss u can exit in tranches, if u think u can avg some loss waiting period can be kept rather than booking immediate loss.

As current situations r not favorable to that sector that stock might not run based on policies, budgets, sector specific & so on.

It has good cash generation but in short to mid period stock will not be able to rally more than 100% for that it needs to generate a compounding returns more than 10% per quarter which current or mid term duration is not favorable for this sector.

So ask this to yourself - R u willing to book huge loss immediately?

If not exiting in tranches will help to minimize loss? & take tax harvesting advantage?

If u r confident about that sector & stock getting dividend will help in minimizing or averaging ur C2C Exit?

If u think from long term perspective then is it worth holding the stock?