Pi Bridge connection with Ninja Trader - Step by Step Manual - other then Neobridge

Algos, strategies, code
1

Similar questions have been asked earlier by a few members already. But everytime they are pointed towards Neobridge Solution, which would work only if you are a subscriber of NeoTradeAnalytics.

I want to ask zerodha team, what solution do they have for those zerodha clients who are not subscribers of NeoTradeAnalytics ?

We have got such a good article, which explains all the steps for connection with Amibroker - http://zerodha.com/z-connect/tradezerodha/pi-bridge/pi-bridge-for-amibroker

But no such article has been prepared so far, which gives the details for connection with Ninja Trader. And all users are just provided this link, which is not sufficient for most retail traders to connect ninjatrader with pi - http://tradelab.in/blog/pi-bridge/158

What is the REAL REASON for not providing a step by step manual for connecting Ninjatrader with pi ? Is it done with the intention to FORCE zerodha clients to susbcribe for NeoTradeAnalytics even if they have proper data feeds like esignal or GFDL or TrueDataIndia etc. ? Why Ninjatrader users are being forced by zerodha to subscribe for a specific data vendor, if they want to connect Ninjatrader with Pi ? Is it legal and is it morally right to do so ?

Either mention that you do not support NinjaTrader connection with Pi on your website, or provide a Detailed and Step by Step Manual to connect Pi with NinjaTrader, just as you have done for Amibroker. Even on this link https://q.zerodha.com/pi/, you have not provided any specific material for NinjaTrader.

If we do not receive a genuine solution from zerodha to this issue of "no proper documentation to connnect ninjatrader with pi, without subscribing to NeoTradeAnalytics, then I will be FORCED to start the same threads on ALL the trading forums. If you have no intention to provide step by step method, then you should not publicize that you support NinjaTrader. Why to make the retail traders so much unnecessarily.

And it is my humble request, do not post this link as solution, because this information is not sufficient. http://tradelab.in/blog/pi-bridge/158

REQUEST for other users - if someone of you have been successful in connecting Ninjatrader with Pi, without using NeoTradeAnalytics, then please share your experience here. That would be a great help for all other users who are trying to do that without success.

Please do not take my post in negative manner, I am just expressing the frustration which is expericed by a lot of clients of zerodha, who are also users of NinjaTrader and want to connect them both.

Thanks and regards

1 Like
2

ok, I have started this thread on traderji now - http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/101431-zerodha-wrong-attitude-ninja-trader-users.html
And I will be asking the same question on all other trading forums as well. So that new users becomes aware of this problem with zerodha.
Thanks and regards

1 Like
3

Hey Trade50, this is not really a question and hence closing it. I am pushing our team to have a bridge built for NT as soon as possible.

4

It has nothing to do with neotrade analytics. One can also use feeds from global data or esignal or even from excel and integrate pi to Pibridge. As most of the traders use Amibroker we have developed dll by which one can directly install and use it.
If one want to link to other third party platforms like ninja trader, metastock, tradestation, or any front end developed in other programming languages it is not feasible to develop dll to each one so we came up with socket programming and few clients could able to successfully integrate Ninjatrader to pi and trade.
If we have many requests to Ninjatrader dll we can start building that dll also.

5

I am also using ninja trader hence would really like to have bridge for NT 7.

6

Yes Lets please have the Ninjatrader dll … Also how do i go about with Socket Programming

7

Any update on bridge for ninja trader ?

8

any update on that

9

Please make a bridge for Ninja Trader. Ninja trader is awesome for Day traders as it has custom hotkeys to place buy and sell orders .

10

Any update on for the Ninja Trader dll project ?