TradingView - Trade From Chart (TFC) Beta Now Live!

[CT143]

@Arockiya_Raja

2 and 4- This is only Trde From Chart feature integration on the Kite TradingView chart.

I haven’t understood this, Please clarify.

[CT143]

@CT143

marketwatch takes a lot of space (1/3rd) and we cannot collepse it

Doing Anything for this?

[CT143]

@CT143

• Seperate Url to do trading on full screen chart

are we getting this

[Arockiya_Raja]

@CT143

I haven’t understood this, Please clarify.

This is only the “Trade From Chart” feature; if you wish to see your watchlist on a popout chart, that is not part of this update.

Trade From Chart just refers to placing/modifying/cancelling orders from the chart and managing the position from the chart.

Making the Marketwatch collapsible on the current Kite main page will look bad on all pages except the chart.

All These things will be addressed in terminal mode.

Seperate Url to do trading on full screen chart

what does this mean?
You can trade on a popout chart, which covers the entire screen on wide screens. F11 will make the chart on a full screen.

[BIR]

He saying like dhan have tv.dhan.co like url when you give for chart and trade

[CT143]

@BIR

Correct, Zerodha’s Version of that, without taking Risk ie. without providing Tradingviews Advanced Library(Platform).

[Arockiya_Raja]

@CT143

Correct, Zerodha’s Version of that, without taking Risk while providing Tradingviews platform.

Responded to it here and in DM previously.

@Arockiya_Raja

We do not have a plan to allow users to trade on the Trading View platform. Relying on a platform over which we have no control is a big risk.

@siva

It’s not about liking or not as Arockiya mentioned but also that is a third party platform and we have no control over it and that is a Big risk which we are not ready to take, even they don’t have office in Inida, said that we will try doing our best.

We will be coming out with terminal mode also in coming months, with that user will have option to select what ever widgets they want to see, like customizing front end.

cannot give a timeline for terminal mode as of now.

[CT143]

@BB789

Could you describe the potential risk? The way I see it, they will still use your APIs and you’re still in control of all orders and risk management team will have full access to all orders/margins from tv, and will be able to do risk estimation and be able to block any thing due to any reason. At the end of the day, the final destination is you. There is nothing you can’t block.

Furthermore, as far as I can see(REST API Specification for Brokers — TradingView India ), they use standard security protocols. Have they had any major issues with any other brokers?

Does having an office in India make them more secure? Or are you hesitating only for legal purposes?

You already opened your APIs. Anyone can implement their own platform and already link to your APIs. How is this different(except for the extra work needed to implement their APIs)?

@Arockiya_Raja ans. this

[Arockiya_Raja]

@CT143

ans. this

sure, will reply in some time in detail.

[BIR]

Ya I want also now about your answer on this topic

[siva]

@CT143

ans. this

We need to get that platform approved as In house platform means we will be responsible if anything goes wrong also clearly NSE states data should stay in India.

Also we feel it is business risk for us, exact reason I can’t say it out as it is our internal decision.
Final point is we are not going to offer direct TV on our platform.

[BIR]

Dekh raha hai Vinod kaise angrezi bol bol ke baat ko ghumaya ja raha hai agar dusre kar sakte hai toh yeh nahi kyu ki yeh saare rules and regulations follow karte hai baaki sare broker toh sebi our nse ke rule nahi follow karte yeh kehna chaa rahe hai , lekin hume yeh lagta hai ki Tv ka library use karne ke liye broker ko bahut fees Dena padta hai our wah zero DHA nahi dena chahta kyu ki Inka profit kam ho jayega

[siva]

@BIR

lekin hume yeh lagta hai ki Tv ka library use karne ke liye broker ko bahut fees Dena padta hai our wah zero DHA nahi dena chahta kyu ki Inka profit kam ho jayega

It will just cost us few lakhs more, it was never about money, as said earlier it is a business call.

[BIR]

That arrogance are same like when all companies started giving touch screen but Blackberry stick on keyboard design in arrogance and not match industry standard and now blackberry is in history and your arrogance is like same @siva

[CT143]

It’s their company, and at the end of the day, it’s their decision.

If someone prefers a different setup, there are always other options.

I kept asking about the TradingView integration again and again because I genuinely like Zerodha’s stability and simplicity. Now that they’ve clearly shared their stand, it helps everyone make informed choices based on what suits them best.

Thank you to everyone who supported me,
and thanks to the Zerodha team for addressing my queries.

[nithin_kumrr]

@BIR

That arrogance are same like when all companies started giving touch screen but Blackberry stick on keyboard design in arrogance and not match industry standard and now blackberry is in history and your arrogance is like same

Hi @BIR , Nithin has answered here.

[BB789]

@siva

We need to get that platform approved as In house platform means we will be responsible if anything goes wrong also clearly NSE states data should stay in India.

I understand business reasons, but this reasoning seems made up after that business reason. I find it hard to believe all data stays in India currently. Do you not use any cloud servers? Zero Amazon or Google servers? If you do, do you have contracts stating that they can have no backups outside India?

[Spy]

Amazon AWS or Google Cloud may have servers in India, and data is likely stored within India.

[M_B1]

When will TFC be opened in kite web ?

[siva]

@M_B1

When will TFC be opened in kite web ?

Next week.