Its my feeling and experience that whenever i put SL in intraday it goes and hit it and comes back to my target . but whenever i don’t put SL trade normally works my way. Today sold pnb at 137 and sl hit at 139 and next sold at 135.2 and again sl hit at 137.2 and later it acheived my target of 130 and 127 both. Its example of today and yesterday same thing happened twice with sbi fut sell. Plz tell me what i am thinking about zerodha is correct or not.anyone else did ezperience the same. Help me plz
2 Likes
This is not true. Today at the last 30 mins PNB was very volatile.
Usually i don’t trade. Yest i did and now today both day i got call from different operators and just within 10 mins of my SL hit.
What did the operator say may I ask?
Trading time was morning 9:30 to 10 am for selling at 137 and sl hit 139 and second one at 1:30 pm sell at 135.2 and 2 pm sl 137.2 hit at 2:03 pm the same thing happened yesterday for selling Sbi fut
Try putting SL a little far then +/-2 pts is not enough and more likely to get hit.
Reply was like sir aap ka trade kaisa chal raha hai…agar loss hua hai toh hum aap ko levels provide karayenge. Maine puch how did u get my number. Then he told we have sources and i can tell u that u just now made a loss…now what shall i think …how did he get such a info
Let me try to undersatdn this. If an SL is hit then you blame the broker is it?
He was selling you a service and you thought he controls market?
Plz don’t misunderstand… I am not a beginner who blames anyone simply… I am observing it very closely from my several trades of BO order. If u don’t believe …i am sorry. But i felt so.so asked to help…when i do MIS order without BO …it mostly ends green …bcoz i avoid SL there
1 Like
He is not the only one…plz read whichever day i trade …i get a call… Thats my doubt…y not on those days when i don’t trade
As per my knowedge market makers and big operators have access to more detailed data, order book depth, this information is provided at additional cost.
Also this is a a common principle that we should never keep a stop loss base on how much you want to lose but should we must see support/resistance and other factors to define our stoploss. Actually you may have kept SL @ 140.5 the resistance +0.5 to avoid whipsaws. Then tour trade may have been very profitable.
Let’s see what zerodha team say about this.
Check your phone man. Does it have post calling service like in the movie Karthik calling karthik. Do you have schizophrenia?
1 Like
This is strange, I never got calls from anyone like this.
Plz update your mobile number to zerodha…sorry just kidding…may be u r lucky
Of course, you are blaming the broker. Your question title itself says that
Now, let me explain the other bits. There are no dark pools and it’s not possible to sell order flows in India. If a stock price reaches a level where you have placed an SL it will be hit. That’s how the market works. Just because your SL got hit twice doesn’t mean there is manipulation. You can throw around unsubstantiated claims.
Sounds like an advisory firm from Indore This is a common issue. Every trader here would have got at least a 100 such calls. There are multiple threads on the same forum about this. Here you go
You are not alone!!!
Check this post
Sorry to all zerodha users…i felt this bcoz of last 4 SL hits in BO order. Yest sbi and today pnb and some others in last few days. I am using zerodha from past 3 years. And keep on getting calls from operators for every trade. The wordings from recent operator that i made a loss today socked me. Getting mobile number is somewhat ok. But getting my trade details and my SL will really arise a doubt that who is providing them such info. Thats it.
Hai Abhishek
Good evening
Your statement is confusing other new traders boss , how can any body else log in to your zerodha account , you are very much wrong on your words and statement
Hope you need to read about zerodha properly
This is one of the best and Reliaable trading platform providing worndetful service to all traders with least trading commissions
We should be great full to Mr Nitin Kamat of zerodha who has given chance to all people to earn money with his company risk more than customers money
As we get huge leverage in bracket orders and futures with very Less commission compared to other competitors
Zerodha will not share anything to others don’t have this confusion in your mind boss
Try to go through all zerodha kite application you tube videos u can understand better
Futures trade is risky u can earn more and equally loose more
U need to have lot of experience for futures trading
Hope u will not make such statement in future
Pls try and clarify your doubts we QNA group will answer your queries to resolve your doubts
Wishing you happy Trading
Suresh Ramaiah
3 Likes