For the sake of completeness,
if anyone from Zerodha is reading this,
please do NOT mistake a vocal minority for a majority opinion.
i should for my own sanity,
But, i am much invested in the TradingQnA forum
to easily let it devolve into a place with low-quality posts without much thought (in my opinion).
If it does, it does, but atleast i would have tried to stop that.
Basically, xkcd: Duty Calls
Basically, i disagree with several of your opinions. (and agree with some others).
I would prefer to continue to call out inconsistencies (in my opinion) whenever i see them.
PS: To be clear,
Please do continue to provide your valuable feedback.
However, i do hope any requests are justified without resorting to sarcasm, hyperbole, and logical fallacies,
while being mindful of other users who are quite happy with the offerings
and would prefer to avoid disruptions just for the sake of change.
PPS: Why don’t i say this to almost every other low-quality comment? Because most folks are not persistent. I don’t see much value in expending effort on folks who perform “drive-by” comments venting their frustrations. @thisisbanerjee Since, i see you continuing to engage on the forum, i wish for the “meat” in your comments, but not the “bones”. I hope you can oblige and make this forum a better place.
( Potential off-topic discussion for this topic-thread. )
This (and the first couple of paragraphs of the previous post) is precisely the hyperbole and sarcasm that i wish to avoid seeing on this TradingQnA forum. Why? Because with such statements, there is no constructive way to discuss/debate the actual topic of interest.
If you are genuinely asserting this,
then i hope you will oblige by listening to what others “more intelligent and knowledgeable” ask/tell you.
If this is hyperbole and sarcasm.
then please try to avoid such patterns of communication,
as it prevents productive conversation.
You? No.
Specific parts of certain posts? Yes. (i hope this is evident upon re-reading any of my previous comments)
There is no chasing or hounding going on.
I am subscribed to almost all categories on this forum,
and i have been reading every single topic-thread in all these categories.
(Nothing unique, i suspect there are many folks with a similar pattern of lurking on forums, reading significantly more than what they post)
Here’s a snapshot of my profile. I hope that helps put my comments in the proper context
Also, in my comment history on this forum,
you will find questioning and criticism in an attempt to further the discussion.
Finally, as i mentioned above, the reason i haven’t replied to other folks’ one-off low-quality posts because they are just venting their frustration and aren’t active members of the community.
i hope all this puts your mind at rest and you do not feel personally attacked anymore.
if/when you see them,
please do post well thought out rebuttals in the respective topic-thread.
That way -
if they are genuine inconsistencies.
the OP would learn a thing or two
and folks reading the topic-thread will also appreciate the additional aspects being highlighted.
if they are misunderstandings,
the OP get to clarify where exactly something was misunderstood.
and folks reading the topic-thread, will avoid making similar incorrect assumptions.
…and the point of having all these discussions publicly (and not in DMs)
is so that a bunch of folks who are interested
can chime-in whenever they see fit and share additional viewpoints.
