Just check range by placing order, it won’t change every minute as such, sometimes it won’t change through out the day.
As said this is not possible it is not like if it is and we are not doing.
As said basket is just a way of entering multiple orders at a time, if any leg in that is rejected/failed one can manually edit and execute that leg again from basket itself.
How you assumed those can be easily done? also why you think we don’t want to help our clients? few things are out of our control and we are accepting that, for this OI thing we can’t do anything for now.
Kindly read again patiently your answers to each point and see that none of them says “why” it can’t be done and says can’t and won’t.and only reason mentioned is that " it is out of your control" … . Niether you have a solution for it. Anyways thx for responding to these. Hope u figure out these sooner as it is 100% clear that Sebi margin benefits would positively benefit users to a large extent, only if OI issue is figured out and this is not just my opinion but very large many of people… Despite all things… .I still like this basket order feature and like ur product and compny pricing business model as against many others… And I hope it take feedbacks positively and come out more better…
@siva-reddy maybe you could allow two longs per one short positions so that if a person wants to rollover longs to other positions he can exit one long and take other positions without getting very excessive margin shortfall . And to support other strategies as well.
Can you provide option to clone the basket. For example, I have made a basket to buy stocks. Now I want to make the same basket to sell the stocks. Cloning will help to the extent that I don’t have to add the stocks again and have to just edit to make changes. Thanks
@nithin@siva-reddy
One suggestion, consider allowing rolling over of long hedge legs outside the range for monthly shorts at least on expiry day. Even Call and trade will be okey, if personal verification is required.
@nithin
This basket order gave me another idea - Can holding be segregated into baskets?
E.g. A user can create a basket called ‘Gold’ and add all SGB, Goldbees, etc from his holding in that basket. A user can create a basket ‘Short Term’ and add the scripts from his holdings which he wants for short term purposes only. Similarly, ‘Auto Sector’, HRITHIK, ‘Long Term’, ‘Retirement’, ‘Sister’s Marriage’, etc custom baskets he can create and add stock to them from his holdings manually.
Adding a new option ‘Baskets’ view in the Holdings dropdown box so the user can select it and see the basket view. His Gold basket has decreased by 2%. His Short Term basket has increased by 20% and so he may think to sell it and exit. And he can further expand the basket Short Term to know which one is down. And so with such a Basket view of holdings, he can see his portfolio in a different way. And plan buy/ sell GTT orders for the whole basket.
What do you think of the idea?
P.S @Anugrah may not like it as it sounds similar to creating a custom smallcase. But custom smallcase involves Rs 100 per smallcase to manage and track. A little difference is that with basket, user is segregating his existing holding only. It’s like arranging or organizing them better.
If you want to check the margin requirements by including all your open positions which are not part of the basket, you can do so by selecting include existing positions. But if you select this, in some cases the required margin might show 0 whereas you might still require margin to place the order. The reason for this is because an order in the basket could potentially be reducing the overall margin, but it might require a margin to place the order. Keep this option disabled if you find it confusing.
It simply mean.
Suppose you have 10 lots of Nifty Longs.
Now if you put in 100 lots of Nifty Sell order in basket, it will show 10 lakhs+ as required margin.
But as soon as you click that including current position tick mark, it calculates margin to zero as you do not require any margins to exit your own 100 lots.
Understood?
Want to report a bug.
Today after basket is executed one of the leg reported back failed status.
In a hurry I re-ordered the leg and when I was back to position book it showed twice the quantity.
Which means order was executed earlier only but it reported back wrong.
Lost nearly 2k in the process!
Also few weeks back my full order got executed and showed as such in Trade book & order book but for long time it showed less quantity in position book. The issue automatically sorted out itself though.
Is it possible that for a spread order — Buy order is executed at limit price but sell order is not executed because of limit price? or Basket means either all orders in basket or none? @shub
