Hey, thanks for the reply. i highly appreciate the approach of solving the problem for all even if just one customer is facing the issue.
These two things are clear.
i am still struggling to reconcile this. i might be over simplifying the things.
lets us assume entire 12.37lkh is collateral and zero cash. then now that i didnot bring in liquid money on to the table, 50 % is provided by zerodha, which should be 12.37/2 = 6.2. why is it more than that ?
one other issue i observed is the account value changed drastically after the period i have posted this. let me explain this by screen shots. these are taken @sunday june 20th 2021
screen shot 1
- account value dropped by more than 2.5 lakhs wth in 4-5 days, without any corresponding losses in the account due to trading or drop in holding value. in fact profit was booked before some shares dropped significantly. i didnt withdraw any money and money is the account itself. what can explain this drop ?
Is my value being influenced by short option premium and long option premium ? if so short option premium is not my money per se. i will not be able to get that amount (shown as account value) when i liquidate the account today right ?
screenshot 2
the span margin and exposure margin is credited and debited daily. But since it is a ledger, it only deals in cash right ?
where is the accounting done for the 50 % collateral ? ( i understand that the calculations are right in the back end as i can verify the same from the interest i am charged for the cash short fall. the only thing is it is confusing when we see such large negative cash balances and scares the shit out of me. it takes a little time to come back to senses)
screen shot 3
this is confusing when i see all the screen shots in one go. i am being told there is negative balance and Account margin is 10.96 lakh in console. i come to kite and i see i have 2.44 lakhs margin in addition to 10.7 lakh.
i realise it is Too long, but i am just looking for better understanding. please help me out.


